Lex Barker as Old Shatterhand

Pierre Brice as Winnetou

Sophie Hardy as Ann

Rik Battaglia as Rollins

Ralf Wolter as Sam Hawkens

Carl Lange as Gouverneur

Miha Baloh as Gomez

Dušan Antonijević as Weißer Büffel

Aleksandar Gavrić as Kid

Ilija Ivezić as Clark

Christian Brückner as Bandit

Veljko Maričić as Vermeulen

Slobodan Dimitrijević as Schneller Panther

Gojko Mitić as Jicarilla

Šime Jagarinac as Roter Pfeil (uncredited)

Karin Dor as (uncredited)

Renato Baldini as (uncredited)

Dragomir Felba as Brown (uncredited)