Ben Johnson as Travis Blue

Joanne Dru as Denver

Harry Carey, Jr. as Sandy

Ward Bond as Elder Wiggs

Charles Kemper as Uncle Shiloh Clegg

Alan Mowbray as Dr. A. Locksley Hall

Jane Darwell as Sister Ledyard

Ruth Clifford as Fleuretty Phyffe

Russell Simpson as Adam Perkins

Kathleen O'Malley as Prudence Perkins

James Arness as Floyd Clegg

Francis Ford as Mr. Peachtree

Fred Libby as Reese Clegg

Jim Thorpe as Navajo Indian

Mickey Simpson as Jesse Clegg

Cliff Lyons as Marshal of Crystal City

Don Summers as Sam Jenkins

Movita as Young Navajo Indian

Hank Worden as Luke Clegg

Chuck Hayward as Jackson (uncredited)

Danny Borzage as Accordionist (uncredited)

Lee Bradley as Leader of the Navajo Band (uncredited)

Nora Bush as Settler (uncredited)

Jane Crowley as Settler (uncredited)

Tex Holden as Settler (uncredited)

George Huggins as Settler (uncredited)

Fred Kennedy as Settler (uncredited)

Al Kunde as Fiddler (uncredited)

Ann Kunde as Settler (uncredited)

Frank McGrath as Posse Member (uncredited)

Evelyn Moriarty as Settler (uncredited)

Eleanore Vogel as Settler (uncredited)