Jay Baruchel as Reed Fish

Alexis Bledel as Kate

Victor Rasuk as Frank Cortez

Schuyler Fisk as Jill

A. J. Cook as Theresa

Katey Sagal as Maureen

Shiri Appleby as Jill Cavanaugh

Chris Parnell as Ralph

Valerie Azlynn as Kate Peterson

DJ Qualls as Andrew

Blake Clark as Irv

Tommy Dewey as Rex

Jim Cody Williams as Cowboy

Boti Bliss as Waitress

Rossif Sutherland as Gabe

David Beggs as Farmer

Jackie Benoit as Imogene Sandstrom

Eugene Smith as Preacher

Reed Fish as John Penner

Peter Alwazzan as Radio Show Caller (voice)

Scott Laster as Floyd Fish (voice)

Todd Fjelsted as Bartender (uncredited)