Robert Pattinson as Samuel Alabaster

Mia Wasikowska as Penelope

David Zellner as Parson Henry

Nathan Zellner as Rufus Cornell

Joseph Billingiere as Zachariah Running Bear

Robert Forster as Old Preacher

Morgan Lund as Bar Creep

David Wingo as Barrel of Laughs

Russell Mael as Prairie Crooner

Gabriel Casdorph as Anton Cornell

Ray Kelleher as Barkeep

Gary Brookins as Sheriff

Landon Weeks as Piano Player

Larry Zeng as Scalped Traveler

Sabrina Chappuis as Angry Traveler

Palmer Scott as Barber

Luana Zellner as Bell Maiden

Ronald Zellner as Photographer

Deanna Milsap as Bathhouse Madam

Angela Summers as Hostess Matilda

Fenton Quinn as Wagon Driver

Josh Lambert as Musician (uncredited)

Toto Miranda as Musician (uncredited)

Yvonne Lambert as Musician (uncredited)

Lauren Gurgiolo as Musician (uncredited)