Jim Belushi as Humpty

Juno Temple as Carolina

Justin Timberlake as Mickey Rubin

Kate Winslet as Ginny

Max Casella as Ryan

Jack Gore as Richie

David Krumholtz as Jake

Robert C. Kirk as Boardwalk Vendor

Tommy Nohilly as Humpty's Friend

Tony Sirico as Angelo

Steve Schirripa as Nick

John Doumanian as Ruby's Bartender

Tom Guiry as Flirtatious Man at Ruby's

Gregory Dann as Fishing Buddy

Bobby Slayton as Fishing Buddy

Michael Zegarski as Fishing Buddy

Geneva Carr as Mary

Ed Jewett as Ruby's Customer

Debi Mazar as Birthday Party Guest

Danielle Ferland as Birthday Party Guest

Maddie Corman as Psychiatrist

Jacob Berger as Watch Salesman

Jenna Stern as Tiny

Michael Striano as Sailor on Phone

John Mainieri as John

Candice A. Buenrostro as Capri Waitress (uncredited)

Matthew Maher as (uncredited)

Amelie McKendry as Woman at Amusement Park (uncredited)

Frankie Petrosino as Beach Boy (uncredited)

Brittini Schreiber as Boardwalk Lady / Soldier's Girlfriend (uncredited)

Jillian Shields as Woman on Boardwalk (uncredited)

Marie Smalley as Coney Island Lady (uncredited)

Nico Petrosino as Beach Boy (uncredited)

Julia Losner as Beachgoer

Leonard Zimmerman as Coney Island Beach Hawker (uncredited)