Elena Nikitina Bick as Dinah

Chris Conner as Jake

Jennifer Gareis as Sarah

Greg Wood as Grandfather

Noah Headley as Steven

Accalia Quintana as Michaela

Alex Yurcaba as Jacob

Jack Buckley as Amos

Hannah Close as Young Sarah

Elena Talan as Washer Woman

Hayden Saunier as Dour Amish Woman

Peter Patrikios as Elroy Dwyer

Zoe Bournelis as Mrs. Dwyer

Lexy Rutt as Dwyer Girl

Chase Rippon as Dwyer Boy

Amy Morse as Amish Woman

Ruth Peebles as Marriage Counselor

Markus Zanders as Jacob's Father

Brian Shenko as Amish Boy

Kerry Shultz as Red Lady