Jeremy Jordan as Jack Kelly

Kara Lindsay as Katherine

Ben Fankhauser as Davey

Andrew Keenan-Bolger as Crutchie

Steve Blanchard as Joseph Pulitzer

Aisha de Haas as Medda Larkin

Ethan Steiner as Les

Tommy Bracco as Spot Conlon

Joshua Burrage as Jojo

Ben Cook as Race

Michael Dameski as Tommy Boy/Scab

Julian DeGuzman as Smalls

Nico De Jesus as Romeo

J.P. Ferreri as Hot Shot

Sky Flaherty as Albert

David Guzman as Ike

Jacob Guzman as Mike

Stephen Hernandez as Vince/Myron

Devin Lewis as Morris Delancey

Nicholas Masson as Mush/Bill

Anthony Norman as Oscar Delancey

Andy Richardson as Kid Blink

Michael Rios as Henry

Jordan Samuels as Specs

Jack Sippel as Darcy/Kenny

Daniel Switzer as Sniper

Andrew Wilson as Willie/Bart

Chaz Wolcott as Buttons

Iain Young as Finch

Anthony Zas as Elmer

John E. Brady as Wiesel/Mr. Jacobi

Kevin Carolan as Governor Roosevelt/Nunzio

Bill Bateman as Bunsen

James Judy as Snyder

Michael Gorman as Mayor

Meredith Inglesby as Hannah/Nun

Mark Aldrich as Seitz

Eric Jon Mahlum as Cop/Patron/Guard

Kaitlyn Frank as Bowery Beauty/Nun

Beth Stafford Laird as Bowery Beauty/Nun