Kelly Macdonald as Agnes

Irrfan Khan as Robert

David Denman as Louie

Daniel Stewart Sherman as Ronnie

Austin Abrams as Gabe

Bubba Weiler as Ziggy

Helen Coxe as Ezster

Mandela Bellamy as Grocery Clerk

Liv Hewson as Nicki

Lori Hammel as Fanny

Lawrence Arancio as Train Conductor

Sebastian Chacon as Puzzlemania Clerk

Barry Godin as Father Kutash

Matthew Shifrin as Subway Singer

Myrna Cabello as Maria

Audrie Neenan as Aunt Emily

Mhari Sandoval as Puzzle Competition MC