Sam Elliott as Jess Sanford

John Corbett as Tom Marks

Sarah Paulson as Beth Marks

Karen Allen as Claire Sanford

Emily Alyn Lind as Vanessa Marks

Elizabeth McLaughlin as Tammy

Max Charles as Gordon Marks

Richard Fitzpatrick as Ted Zachary

Jeremy Akerman as Reverend Bob Danforth

Eric Keenleyside as Wade Miller

Tegan Moss as Adult Vanessa

Dawn McKelvie Cyr as Abby Hildman

Rhonda McLean as Reader

Glen Lefchak as Rick Zackary

Jennie Raymond as Rita

Joshua Rush as Actor (voice, uncredited)