Liev Schreiber as Drew Hagel

Marisa Tomei as Carrie Manning

Peter Sarsgaard as Quint Manning

Maya Hawke as Shannon Hagel

Alex Wolff as Ian Warfield

Betty Gabriel as Ronnie Hagel

Aasif Mandvi as Godeep

Paul Sparks as Jon

Fred Hechinger as Jamie Manning

John Ventimiglia as David

Dominic Colón as Roberto Jarvis

James Waterston as Andy

Fredric Lehne as Detective Flowers

Daryl Edwards as Detective Gore

Greta Quispe as Nanny

Alex Yiakoumatos as Manning Twin #1

Nick Yiakoumatos as Manning Twin #2

Carson McCalley as Tim

Julia Greer as WMV Associate

Mark Blum as Rex

Eva Kaminsky as Diane

David Gibson as Headmaster

Marisa Ryan as Ella

Maxwell Whittington-Cooper as Brendon

Loni Ackerman as Carrie's Mother

Aaron Roman Weiner as Trainer

Christiane Seidel as Godeep's Wife

Madeline Scanlon as Emily

Rachelle Carson-Begley as News Reporter

Greta Watson as Reporter #1

Lawrence Smith as Relentless Reporter

Amanda Barron as Journalist

Michael Wren Gucciardo as Toby (Banker at Quints House) (uncredited)

Blair Lewin as Young Carrie (uncredited)

Ron Maestri as Parent (uncredited)

Christine McCann as Board Member (uncredited)