Cole Hauser as John Wright

Sean H. Scully as Michael Miller

Annika Marks as Elizabeth Barnes

Randall Batinkoff as Bobby Baker

Hallie Todd as Melinda Miller

Peter Onorati as Frank Stevens

Bob McCracken as Pastor Barnes

Casey Moss as Scott Baker

Taylor Dearden as Joanna Miller

Virginia Tucker as Jamie Osder

Michael John Madden as Deck Hines

Joey Luthman as Ronnie Leadman

Peggy Etra as Peggy Gibson

Jeanine Jackson as Annie Stevens

Roy Stanton as Sheriff Doug Hamilton

Alfred E. Rutherford as Les Kriskie

Florence Schiff as Katie Miller

Scott MacDonald as Witt Chambers

Ithica Tell as Principal Phelps

Haley Talbot as Lori Baker

Nathan Kornelis as Joe Leadman

Michael Lowry as Paul Osder

Erin McIntosh as Tori

Blaine Palmer as Al Harper

Ted de Chatelet as Pete

Ted Rooney as Mr. McCormick

David Manzanares as J.L. Sarkin

Jana Lee Hamblin as Jill Osder

Rachael Perrell Fosket as Christina Wooten

Dan Gable as Self

Pat Janowski as Karen Hamilton

Travis Bryant as Self

Jeffery Checketts as Jeff Hamilton

Randy Lewis as Self

Adam Nakanishi as Wrestler #1

Jennifer Lanier as Mrs. Harris

Erin McGarry as Linda Leadman

Olivia Longin as Lauren

Seth Pascale as Charlie