Greg Kinnear as Phil

Emily Mortimer as Alicia

Taylor Schilling as Sam

Kurt Fuller as Jerome

Bradley Whitford as Michael Fisk

Luke Wilson as Detective Welling

April Cameron as Rahel

Megan Charpentier as Molly McGuire

Sarah Dugdale as Kara Fisk

Jay Duplass as Malcolm

Robert Forster as Bing Fisk

Christina Jastrzembska as Mrs. Konwiser

Jagen Johnson as Booze Clerk

Angela Moore as Nurse

Nicole Oliver as Rosemary

William B. Davis as Father Grant

Rukiya Bernard as Nora

Peter Bryant as Cop

Kirby Morrow as Childhood Friend

Brittany Mitchell as Nurse 2 / Pizza Server

Alex Trebek as Alex Trebek

Doug Abrahams as Maître D'