Lacey Chabert as Tess Harper

Brennan Elliott as Logan O'Connor

Barbara Niven as Aunt Candace

John Kapelos as Chief Chauncey O'Connor

Romaine Waite as Winston Sams

Lara Jean Chorostecki as Christina Blake

Alex Paxton-Beesley as Abby Miller

Kimberly J. Brown as Angela

Kyle Buchanan as Lyle Clark

Lindsay Owen Pierre as Emory Nelson

Genevieve Kang as Josephine

Janet Porter as Bethany

Kintaro Akiyama as Elliot

Will Shortz as Police Officer

Richard Ashton as Richards the Diamond Dealer

Jeffrey R. Smith as Baxter the Farmer

Josette Jorge as Librarian

Carrie Schiffler as Clerk

Racine Bebamikawe as Nurse Bethany

Jason Díaz as Clayton

Brenda Robins as Mildred Clark

Hannah Kanter as Student Worker

Bobby Daniels as Minister

Eryk Simon as Angela's Fiance / Groom