Samuel H. Levine as David

Ron Rifkin as Josef

Christopher McCann as Herschel

Richard Topol as Zalman

Mark Margolis as Itzik

Brooke Bloom as Rachel

Alex Hurt as Bruno

Carson Meyer as Alicia

Zane Pais as Nathan

Eleanor Reissa as Mrs. Greenberg

Gera Sandler as Simon

Michael Broadhurst as Driver 1

Lawrence Jansen as Itzik's Son

Chris Perfetti as Eric

Chinaza Uche as Teacher

Zuzanna Szadkowski as Rivka

Lili Rosen as Principal Rabbi

Jonathan Raviv as Junior Rabbi

Elizabeth Loyacano as Mrs. Namovsky

Amir Levy as Driver 2

Mark Bruk as Rabbi

Riley Barnes as Yeshiva Bully 1

Drew Reade as Yeshiva Bully 2

Sacha Seberg as Mr. Zeydenbaum

Peter Von Berg as One Armed Russian