Malcolm Barrett as Derrick

Lyndie Greenwood as Susan

Jonah Ray Rodrigues as Matt

Felicia Day as Molly

Gavin Stenhouse as Bennie Taylor

Wil Wheaton as David

Rachel Bloom as Ellie

Motoki Maxted as Jax

Amir Talai as Amir

Laurel Toupal as Becky

Ben Weinswig as Andy

Willow Beuoy as Lauren

Alexander Ward as Animal Pooka

Gene Freeman as Demon Pooka

Ken Dickason Sr. as Bar Patron

Lucas Hyde as Bartender

Jessie Epstein as Pooka Livestreamer

Harrison Meloeny as Andy's Colleague

Laurie Perez as Reporter