Ikechukwu Ufomadu as Inspector Ike

Matt Barats as Harry Newcombe

Ana Fabrega as Deputy Hawthorne

Grace Rex as Jan

John Early as Chip Conrad

Aparna Nancherla as Fran

Anthony Oberbeck as Deputy Dinardo

Jessica Damouni as Rita Conrad

Dorothi Fox as Esther

Alex Goldberg as Al

River L. Ramirez as Loretta

Stavros Halkias as Confused Waiter for 'Al's Pizza'

Colin Burgess as Actor

Eudora Peterson as Actor

Caroline Yost as Actor

Dan Arnes as Wealthy Criminal

Rhys Grady as Christmas Criminal

Amy Zimmer as Stage Magician

Tynan DeLong as Phantom

Carly Lovejoy as Rockette

Leah Motzkin as Rockette

Sarah Madden as Rockette

Alex Tatarsky as Mime

Ryan McGlade as Kabuki Guy

Jen Goma as Actor

Mike McKay as TV Announcer