Diane Foster as Audrey

David Backus as The Orphan Killer

Matt Farnsworth as Mike

James McCaffrey as Detective Jones

John Savage as Detective Walker

Karen Young as Sister Mary

Charlotte Maier as Sister Constance

Spencer List as Young Marcus

Dana DeVestern as Young Audrey

Edward Winrow as Father Chuck

Devin Foster as Skateboarder

Ramon Villa as Sanchez the Janitor

Seif El Bawdrey as Vinny the Janitor

Olivia Rosendahl as Jump Rope Orphan

Samantha Matarante as Urban Ledgend Teen #1

April Hautea as Urban Ledgend Teen #2

Ivan Martin as Math Teacher

Margot White as Jenny Miller

Mike Doyle as Dad Miller

Golden Farnsworth as Boy Marcus

Ivy Farnsworth as Baby Audrey

Hector Lincoln as Intruder - Murderer

Allison Salvetti as Screaming Orphan

Walter Masterson as Marcus Miller

Ezra Knight as Simon - Orderly

Jon David Casey as Jerry - Orderly

Matthew Arkin as Bob - Orderly

Linda Bothwell-Murphy as Naughty Nun

Lesline Lewis as Jamaican Nun

Celina Vignaud as Orphan Kid

Michaela M. Hill as Orphan Kid

Ian Colletti as Orphan Kid Playing Basketball

Lucian Maisel as Orphan Kid Playing Basketball

Richard Charles Stevens as Robert

Kenya Brome as Reporter (uncredited)

Federico Castelluccio as Dr. Morris (uncredited)

Brian Delate as John (uncredited)

Maria Diaz as Nun (uncredited)

Michael Ray Escamilla as Hector (uncredited)

Matthew Gooley as Orderly (uncredited)

Carrie Needham as Mike's Mother (uncredited)

Drew Needham as Policeman (uncredited)

Karen Olivo as Angie (uncredited)

Josh Pesin as Policeman (uncredited)

Jeff Velez as News Photographer (uncredited)

William Wayne as Marcus' Orderly (uncredited)