Crystal Bernard as Debbie Laramie

Bobby Edner as Hayden Laramie

Brian Dennehy as Bobby Brown

William Shockley as Kent Dylan

Beth Grant as Frances Loren

Ken Jenkins as Reverend McNamara

Nick Searcy as Reverend Ellington

Brad Stine as John Sullivan

Danielle Dearing as Church Goer

Paul Ganus as Bart

Elizabeth Dennehy as Helen Brown

Lorilynn Failor as Twyla Twain

Loy Edge as Nate Twain

Michael Tyler Henry as Donnie Bottinelli

Kelly Lazarus as Beth

Marianne Muellerleile as Doris Fargo

Timothy Stack as Eugene Fennig

Michael Seaman as Scott Sullivan

Jim O'Heir as Fred Fargo

Lou Beatty Jr. as Trevor Goodman

Cynthia Boris as Church Goer

Brianne Costa as Snobby Girl

Doug Cox as Izzy

Lisa Angelina Green as Shopkeeper

Bailey Huff as Schoolyard Bully

Chris Kato as Valet

Kenny Kato as Student

Shelby Kern as Bailey's Friend

Robbie Moore as Church Member

Emily Pennington as Bailey

Connie Ray as Patsy Nellis

Leslie Riley as Teacher

Evan Sabara as Kip

Emma Stack as Chloe

Winnie Stack as Gracie

Jennifer Titus as Young Mother

Lindsay Weems as Waitress