Karen Knox as Holly Frost

Jessica Clement as Faith Pringle

Joseph Cannata as Chris Pringle

Alex Harrouch as Chad Pringle

Michael Xavier as Sheriff Noel

Perrie Voss as Cookie Winters

Franco Lo Presti as Cameraman Sam

Rashaana Cumberbatch as Joy Wreath

Miriam McDonald as Mayor Danica Bells

Daniel Kash as Kevin Kevins

Jana Peck as Satan / Santa

Juno Rinaldi as Aunt Becky

Maya Misaljevic as Little Holly

Fabienne Hodge-Carter as Little Cookie

Victoria Kucher as Eve Winters

Josette Halpert as Candace

Ucal Shillingford as Cole

Xavier Lopez as Jack

Morgan Lever as John Smith

Christo Graham as Cameron

Marni Van Dyk as Kristy

Daniel Falk as Nick Winters