Candace Cameron Bure as Aurora Teagarden

Niall Matter as Nick Miller

Marilu Henner as Aida Teagarden

Lexa Doig as Sally Allison

Peter Benson as Dt. Arthur Smith

Miranda Frigon as Lynn Liggett-Smith

Dylan Sloane as Phillip Pifer

Ellie Harvie as Lillian Tibbett

Cole Vigue as Davis Mettle

Brad Harder as Officer Heard

Ecstasia Sanders as Amanda Gaines

Matthew Kevin Anderson as David Kotkin

Rhiannon Fish as Melissa Needham

Adam Beauchesne as Hal Needham

Tony Gulati as Billy Wickman

Sarah-Jane Redmond as Bianca Avery

David James Lewis as Ben Avery

Yoshie Bancroft as Misty Wagner

Linda Pollard as Older Woman

Madeleine Kelders as Minister

Malcom Masters as Undercover Cop

Karen Khunkhun as Reporter

Sharon Crandall as Bank Manager