Molly C. Quinn as Sister Mary

Jake Horowitz as Benjamin

Hayley McFarland as Sister Agnes

Rachel True as Sister Ruth

Zandy Hartig as Sister Honey

Chris Browning as Father Black

Ben Hall as Father Donaghue

Mary Buss as Mother Superior

Chris Sullivan as Curly

Sean Gunn as Paul Satchimo

Cait Brasel as Sister Dodd

Cheryl McConnell as Sister Claude

Azrial Greene as Sister Mawd

Rita Scranton as Sister Gertrude

Ginger Gilmartin as Wanda

Bruce Davis as Earl

Van Quattro as Father Exley

Chris Freihofer as Father Cappa

Ron Sutor as The Bishop

Jacob Snovel as Pete (uncredited)

Lorri Bohnert as Comedy Club Patron (uncredited)

Garrett O'Brien as Grocery Store Shopper / Comedy Club Patron (uncredited)