Oakes Fegley as Adam

David Duchovny as James

Eric Hanson as Jacob #1

Jason Dowies as Jacob #2

Larry Pine as Jacob #3

T.R. Knight as Jacob Jr.

Harrison Hughes as Young Adam

Kim Jackson Wheeler as Mary

Billy Slaughter as The Bounty Hunter

Kevin Wayne as Rex

K. Steele as Gwen

Tracy Pfau as Crystal

Jeanne Caldarera as Prison Receptionist

Garrett Kruithoff as Officer Charles

Gerardo Davila as Julio

René Mena as Immigrant

K.J. Baker as Rebecca

Noah Brand as Abraham

Holly Bonney as Sarah

Tatum Meadow Witt as Esther

Hannah Smith Phillips as Hannah

Cedric Greenway as Sheriff Daniels

Dana Namerode as Linda

Adrian Lockett as Eddie

Trace McMullin as Dylan

Hastings McMullin as Baby Adam

Darryl Cox as Seminar Host

David Moncrief as Adam's First Partner

Mitch Westphal as Adam's Second Partner

Hartleigh Buwick as Adam's Mother