James Roday Rodriguez as Shawn Spencer

Dulé Hill as Burton Guster

Timothy Omundson as Carlton Lassiter

Maggie Lawson as Juliet O'Hara

Kirsten Nelson as Karen Vick

Jazmyn Simon as Selene

Corbin Bernsen as Henry Spencer

Allen Maldonado as Alan Decker

Kurt Fuller as Woody Strode

Curt Smith as Curt Smith

Ray Wise as Father Peter Westley

Katie Findlay as Bryn

Leanne Lapp as Waitress

Sophia Reid-Gantzert as Lily Lassiter

BJ Harrison as Rental Manager

Sage Brocklebank as Buzz McNab

Bethany Brown as Whitney