Robert De Niro as Paul Vitti

Billy Crystal as Dr. Ben Sobel

Lisa Kudrow as Laura MacNamara Sobel

Chazz Palminteri as Primo Sidone

Kresh Novakovic as '50s Gangster

Bart Tangredi as Young Vitti, Sr.

Michael Straka as Young Dominic Manetta

Joseph Rigano as Dominic Manetta

Joe Viterelli as Jelly

Richard C. Castellano as Jimmy Boots

Molly Shannon as Caroline

Max Casella as Nicky Shivers

Frank Pietrangolare as Tuna

Kyle Sabihy as Michael Sobel

Bill Macy as Dr. Isaac Sobel

Rebecca Schull as Dorothy Sobel

Pat Cooper as Salvatore Masiello

Leo Rossi as Carlo Mangano

Aasif Mandvi as Dr. Shulman

Neil Pepe as Carl

Tony Darrow as Moony

Michael Haley as Producer

Ian Marioles as Soundman

DonnaMarie Recco as Sheila

Vince Cecere as Tino

Jimmie Ray Weeks as FBI Agent Steadman

Bob Cea as FBI Agent Ricci

William Hill as FBI Agent Provano

Ira Wheeler as Scott MacNamara

Luce Ennis as Belinda MacNamara

Elizabeth Bracco as Marie Vitti

Gina Gallagher as Theresa Vitti

Francesca Mari as Anna Vitti

Vinny Vella, Jr. as Anthony Vitti

Mickey Bruno as Miami Soldier

Dave Corey as Miami Hall Guard

Fred Workman as Justice of the Peace

Daniel W. Barringer as Dream Sequence Gunman

John Polce as Dream Sequence Gunman

Drew Eliot as Priest at Funeral

Grace DeSena as Tommy Angels' Widow

New York Joe Catalfumo as Exuberant Mourner

Michael Guarino, Jr. as Stevie Beef

Michael Harkins as Paretti's Family

Paula Raflo as Paretti's Family

Ondine Harris as Paretti's Family

Matthew Vega as Paretti's Family

Clem Caserta as Handsome Jack

Tony Ray Rossi as Potatoes

Judith Kahan as Elaine Felton

Ted Neustadt as Rabbi

Pasquale Cajano as Joe Baldassare

Gene Ruffini as Frankie Zello

Alfred Sauchelli, Jr. as Mo-Mo

Tony DiBenedetto as Johnny "Bigs"

Frank Aquilino as Eddie "Cokes"

Tony Bennett as Tony Bennett

Joseph Bonanno as Joseph Bonanno (archive footage)

Joe Gallo as Joe Gallo (archive footage)

Kenny Alfonso as Car Chase Driver (uncredited)

Phillip V. Caruso as Wedding Photographer (uncredited)

Anthony Caso as Johnny Angel (uncredited)

Richard D'Alessandro as Gangster (uncredited)

Trish Dempsey as Hotel Guest (uncredited)

Tony Devon as Bobby Angel (uncredited)

Benim Foster as SWAT Team Leader (uncredited)

Russell Gibson as Mafio Capo (uncredited)

Joseph Hardin as Man in Commercial (uncredited)

James Morricone as Wise Guy (uncredited)

Michael Rothberger as Soldier (uncredited)

Paul Scannapieco as Freddie the Fruitman (uncredited)

Vinny Vella as Mobster at Meeting (uncredited)