Joe List as Jeff

Sarah Tollemache as Beth

Paula Plum as Mom

Robert E. Walsh as Dad

Tara Pacheco as Naomi

Robert Kelly as Bobby

Richard O'Rourke as Grandpa

Dorothy Dwyer as Darlene

Nick Di Paolo as Uncle Kevin

Chris Walsh as Uncle Mark

Tony Viveiros as Tony

Lynne Koplitz as Tricia

Courtland Jones as Brenda

Bill Scheft as Bill

Louis C.K. as Therapist

Oliver Solomon as Dr. White

Katie Hannigan as Young Woman

Gary Vider as Sneaky Man

Allan Havey as Dentist

Liz Miele as Hygienist