Bethany Joy Lenz as Lucy Hardgrove

Kristoffer Polaha as Jack Huston

Colton Little as Claude Lancaster

A.K. Benninghofen as Margaret

Annabelle Borke as Ava Hayward

Jennifer Cortese as Peggy

Jonathan Frakes as Winston

David Alexander as William West

Tommy Cresswell as Michael Balaban

Robert Picardo as Harold Balaban

Caity Brewer as Becca

Philena Gilmer as Sandra

Mary Elizabeth McDonough as Director

Alphie Hyorth as Angel

Ray Fawley as James's Father

Bobbie Peterson as Tree Lighting Patron

Barbara Nuss Stiles as Present Day Tourist

Josh Yarusinsky as Waiter

Wes Brown as Charlie

Rachel Boston as Lucy, Actress