Bobby Driscoll as Peter Pan (voice)

Kathryn Beaumont as Wendy Darling (voice)

Hans Conried as Captain Hook / Mr. Darling (voice)

Bill Thompson as Mr. Smee (voice)

Heather Angel as Mrs. Darling (voice)

Paul Collins as John Darling (voice)

Tommy Luske as Michael Darling (voice)

Candy Candido as Indian Chief (voice)

Tom Conway as Narrator (voice)

June Foray as Mermaid / Squaw (voice) (uncredited)

Margaret Kerry as Mermaid (voice, uncredited)

Jeffrey Silver as Lost Boy (voice, uncredited)

Tony Butala as Lost Boy (voice)

Carol Coombs as (voice) (uncredited)

Karen Kester as (voice) (uncredited)