Elizabeth Montgomery as Lizzie Borden

Fionnula Flanagan as Bridget Sullivan

Ed Flanders as Hosea Knowlton

Katherine Helmond as Emma Borden

Don Porter as George Robinson

Fritz Weaver as Mr. Andrew Borden

Bonnie Bartlett as Sylvia Knowlton

Helen Craig as Mrs. Abby Borden

Hayden Rorke as Julien Ralph

Gloria Stuart as Store customer

John Beal as Dr. Bowen

Alan Hewitt as Mayor Coughlin

Gail Kobe as Alice Russell

Amzie Strickland as Adelaide Churchill

Robert Symonds as Andrew Jennings

Iggie Wolfington as Store Proprietor

John Zaremba as Judge Blaisdell

J. Edward McKinley as Marshall Hilliard

Norman Stuart as Dr. Wood

Jon Lormer as Bailiff

Lynn Wood as Mrs. Raymond

Olan Soule as Eli Bence

Judson Morgan as Justice Morgan

John Alvin as Dr. Draper

Patricia Wilson as Hannah Reagan

Tracie Savage as Young Lizzie

Joan Crosby as Companion

Jason Johnson as Jury Foreman