January Jones as Missie Davis

Logan Bartholomew as Willie / Nate

Dale Midkiff as Clark Davis

Katherine Heigl as Marty Claridge

Kesun Loder as Aaron Davis

Logan Arens as Arnie Davis

Mackenzie Astin as Grant Thomas

Cliff DeYoung as Zeke

Matthew Peters as Brian Murphy

Michael Bartel as Willie at 15

Dominic Scott Kay as Mattie

Blaine Pate as Sam

Cara DeLizia as Annie Walker

Robert F. Lyons as Doc Watkins

Douglas Fisher as Edward Trumball

E.J. Callahan as Asa

Katia Coe as Clara

Gary Sievers as Ranxher

Tara Lynne Barr as Student (uncredited)

R. Baxter as Townsman (uncredited)

Joshua Michael Kwiat as Surveyor (uncredited)

Lance Lanfear as Surveyor Camp Horserider (uncredited)

Danielle McKee as Townswoman (uncredited)