Danny Nucci as Benny Rodriguez

Keanu Pires as Young Tommy

Chauncey Leopardi as Squints

Sarah Deakins as Sara Santorelli

Cole Heppell as D.P.

Kai James as Timber

Brandon Olds as Two Ton

Cainan Wiebe as Ryan

Renzo Carbonel as Roll

Samuel Patrick Chu as Wok

Ryan Drescher as Wings

Meshach Peters as Q

Luke Perry as Tommy Santorelli

Chris Gauthier as Officer Pork Chop

Paul Jarrett as Earl Needman

Alexander Ludwig as E.J.

Leila Johnson as Judy

Peter Grasso as Bud

Michael Antonakos as Lou

Jay Brazeau as Doctor Parker

Don MacKay as Chairman

Brendan Beiser as Umpire

John Kruk as St. Agnes Coach

Jason Bryden as Theater Manager / Usher

Michael Adamthwaite as Dodger Pitcher

Michael O'Shea as Coach

Scott Anderson as Ray

Malcolm Scott as Agent

Sonja Bennett as Pearl

Dawn Chubai as Reporter

Winnie Hung as Nurse

Chris Shields as Doctor Washington

Dean Hinchey as Adult Ryan

Brian Dobson as Narrator (voice)