Jack Scalia as Joseph 'Joey' Buttafuoco

Alyssa Milano as Amy Fisher

Phyllis Lyons as Mary Jo Buttafuoco

Leo Rossi as Bobby Buttafuoco

J.E. Freeman as Det. Marty Algar

Peter Van Norden as Joey's Attorney

Lawrence Tierney as Joey Buttafucco's Father

Anne DeSalvo as Roseann Fisher

Michael Bowen as Paul Makely

Jack Kehler as Elliot Fisher

Jeff Perry as Amy's Attorney

Georgia Emelin as Lizzy

Mike Girard Sheehan as Vince Donnelly

Nancy Cassaro as Maria

Nick Corello as Frankie

Joseph G. Fowler as Fred Klein

Tiiu Leek as Sally Anzio

Debra Snell as Jenny Seals

Erick Avari as Surgeon

Paddi Edwards as Pat Connery

Adam LaVorgna as Paulie Buttafuoco

Cassy Friel as Jesse Buttafuoco

Mort Sertner as Judge Marvin Goodman

Donna Ekholdt as Sophie

Robert Jason as Band Singer

Duke Moosekian as Ride Operator

Paul Cain as British Reporter

Frank Pesce as Rehab Patient

Tyrone Tann as Vietnamese Kid

Bo Dietl as Priest

Leslie Ann Hill as Reporter

Marco Verdier as Jason

Bobby Santo as Bodybuilder

Lee Taylor-Allan as Nurse