Sam Hennings as Benjamin Steed

Brenda Strong as Mary Ann Steed

Eric Johnson as Joshua Steed

Alexander Carroll as Nathan Steed

Brighton Hertford as Melissa Steed

Julia Cunningham as Rebecca Steed

Cody Sanders as Matthew Steed

Sarah Bastian as Lydia Steed

Emily Podleski as Jessica Steed

Jonathan Scarfe as Joseph Smith

Melanie Hawkins as Emma Smith

Frank Ashmore as Martin Harris

Curtis Andersen as Carl Rogers

Jeff Ham as Obadiah

Giulia Pagano as Mother Smith

Raphael Sbarge as Parley Pratt

Corbin Allred as John Griffith

Matthew Carlton as George Simpson

Michael Bowen as Robert Johnson

Meredith Salenger as Caroline Mendenhall

Connor Chavarria as Will Mendenhall

R. D. Call as Boggs

Jeni Lamm Bewer as Mormon Woman

Peggy Walton-Walker as Woman #2

Danny Nelson as Reverend Samuel Bogart

Andrew Bowen as Brigham Young

Nakotah LaRance as Pidgeon

Andy Stahl as Joshua Sexias

Ed Haggard as Philo Driggs

Jayne Morgan as Annie

Greg Welsch as Brother Rawson

Andrew Ruse as Bully

Kubbi as Miranda

Bobby Daniels as Eli

Stephen Michael Ayers as Father Smith

Jeffrey Buckner Ford as Jacob Bump

Sam Sharp as Man

Mary Jennifer Littleton as Margaret

Kevin Wayne as Mormon Man

Haidyn Rankin as Rachel

Bruce McKinnon as Warren Parrish

Michael Ormsby as Little Joshua

Melissa Ritz as Woman

Fisher Neal as William Smith

William David Witt as Church Elder

Chase Condrone as Mormon Boy (uncredited)

Wes Murphy as Gunman (uncredited)

Lee Vervoort as Townsperson (uncredited)