Jason Ritter as Peter

Jess Weixler as Vandy

Jesse L. Martin as Paul

Tracie Thoms as Marissa

Noah Bean as Andrew

David Rasche as Alan

Bobby Aiello as Male Bartender

Bruce Altman as Dad

Dana Eskelson as Emma

Kristina Klebe as Michelle

Lawrence Michael Levine as Mike

Zak Orth as Keith

Maryann Plunkett as Mom

Gregg Prosser as Wedding Guest