Tim Higgins as Ben Holland

Kara Mulrooney as Lydia

Mark Metcalf as Sheriff Roy

Barry Bostwick as George

Veronica Cartwright as Edith

Mark Borchardt as Cashier

Kenny Somerville as Kenny

Tony Wood as Lieutenant

Alicia Rice as Waitress Kathy

Cynthia Lund as Librarian

Jenn Morris Fodden as Tea Party Lady

Judy Dondlinger as Tea Party Lady

Catherine Egger as Tea Party Lady

Marce Leonard as Tea Party Lady

Jean Dvorak as Tea Party Lady

Cecelia Condit as Friend of Edith

Bella Wholey Ortiz as Young Edith

Diane Richardson as Tea Party Lady

Amanda Tollefson as Pie Waitress

Josh Peterson as Young Roy

Arthur Nienhuis as Friend of Kenny

Mark Batta as Sheriff's Deputy

Ted Dulany as Cult Leader

Miles O'Neil as Sheriff's Deputy

Nick Sommer as The Tattered Man

Anthony Wood as Lieutenant