Jackson Tessmer as Jeremy Finkle

Jeff Evans as Narrator

Kealan Rivera as Jack

Logan Allen as Classmate

Amber Baylis as Classmate

Anna Grace Davidson as Classmate

Josephine Dyckman as Classmate

Annalea Nichols as Classmate

Isaiah Pinkerton as Classmate

Zacharia Satten as Classmate

Noah Thomas as Classmate

Vinny Alfano as Cookie Person

Jorge Benitez as Cookie Person

Ahmed T. Brooks as Cookie Person (as Ahmed Brooks)

Sandra Diola as Cookie Person

Nichole Visco as Cookie Person