Stephen Baldwin as Chad Chase

Donald Faison as Jonathan

Erin Cahill as Carla Finney

Chynna Phillips as Mrs. Cameron

Isabella Hofmann as Sue

Joey Fatone as Tino

Tessie Santiago as Jennifer

Andrew Morgado as (voice)

Stacey Arwen Raab as Church Member

Michael Monks as Pastor Skip Finney

Samantha Baldwin as Girl in Confessional

London Fuller as London

Andriana Manfredi as Gretchen

Ryan O'Quinn as DJ Jazzy Carl

Diana Matlak as Youth Worker

Bob Sáenz as Bernard

Bridget Albaugh as Sheila

Sedona Fuller as Sedona

Brandy Futch as Reporter

Dennis Nicomede as Church Member

Harvey B. Jackson as Church Member

Wes Halula as Mort

Thor Ramsey as Guy Sides

Christian Janner as Guy in Church

Todd Wilkerson as Dr. Knott

Christopher Shawn Shaw as Efficient Stagehand

Apollo Garza as Church Goer

Ricky Titus-Lam as Jeremy

Clancy McCartney as Blaise

John McGalliard as Laser Tag Stud

William Baldwin as Mr. Cameron