Jessica Lang as Emma Bradley

Jadon Cal as Steve Clayton

Charles White Jr. as Officer Greg

Michael Vincent Berry as Sheriff Murray

Jim Fitzpatrick as Mr. Bradley

Andrew Wagenheim as Mr. Seitz

Kyle Prue as Ben / Killer (masked performer)

Justin Illig as Killer (unmasked performer)

Jennings Brower as Jet

Amber Newman as Ma

Peter Donahue as Chuck

Ted Gibson as Leroy

Matthew Cantazaro as Dirk

Michael Cherbini as Mutt

Ethan Rich as Bobby Stone

David Raizor as Mr. Henderson

Joey DiSomma as Coach Russo

Reed Foster as Timmy

Noah Diggs as Ricky

Sara Eklund as Donna McCormick

Leonardo Scattereggia as Mr. Weebly

Chloe Friedman as Stacey

Foster King as Henry

Sydnee Moberg as Kelsey

Caroline Newsome as Maddie

Dominique Otto as Becca

David Prue as Johnny

Gabriella Sands as Sarah

Will Sippel as Stewart Minkle

Alex Lecca as Bully #2

Austin Estremera as Bully #3

Jay Jenkins as Officer Jordy

Connor Colquhoun as Killer (voice)