Gabriel Byrne as Sheriff Ambrose

Thomas Jane as Thaddeus

Isaiah Mustafa as Cicero

Anna Camp as Alice

Nat Wolff as Young Jim

Richard Dreyfuss as Edgar

Aimee Garcia as Isabel

Zach McGowan as Dunnigan

Danny Bohnen as Marcus O'Sullivan

Emma Kenney as Rebecca Davies

Scottie Thompson as Emma Dunnigan

Isabella Ruby as Josephine Wright

Tanaya Beatty as Violet Running Horse

Lia Marie Johnson as Eugenia Martin

Jenna Ciralli as Jane

Kate Britton as Lorelei

Emily Rasmuss as Bette

Tim Montana as George Pickens