Kiernan Shipka as Jamie

Nico Hiraga as Ben

Caleb Hearon as Palmer

Ava DeMary as Claire

Charlie Hall as Simon

Tramell Tillman as Coach Reese

Joel Kim Booster as Ethan

Miles Gutierrez-Riley as Lukas

Zach Zucker as Tyler

Christine Taylor as Diane

Kevin Yamada as Norman

Sophie Zucker as Megan Mendelson

Darius 'Nastyelgic' Jackson as Bouncer

Olivia Nikkanen as Kelly

Apoorva Gundeti as Erin

Subho Basu as Luther

Juliana Davies as Young Jamie

Violet Tinnirello as Young Megan

Jason Babinsky as Mr. Mendelson

Jake Bongiovi as Kellan

Gabriela Safa as Sofia

Sage Ftacek as Kurt

Kate Pittard as Samantha Kosar

Mahayla Laurence as Ciara

Chloe Troast as Hannah

Adi Dixit as Alec

Savy Jackson as Amelia

Stavros Halkias as Fat Bald AirPods Guy

Tuffy Questell as Campus Security Guard

Ethan Rhys Walker as Goatee Guy

Stephee Bonifacio as Girl

Aja Hinds as Tyler's Girlfriend (uncredited)