Donal Logue as Misfit

Lucy Punch as Candace

Kim Dickens as Rhonda

Abraham Benrubi as Citizen Dave

Silas Weir Mitchell as Wild Man Sam

Charles Esten as John Tipton

James Le Gros as Rabbi

Jason Matthew Smith as LH Manson

Marisa Ryan as Montana

Timm Sharp as Scratch

W. Earl Brown as Sailor