Paul Rudd as John (voice)

Patton Oswalt as Elliot (voice)

Hannibal Buress as The Nerd King (voice)

Riki Lindhome as Linda (voice)

Kate Micucci as Sally (voice)

Mike Judge as Archie (voice)

Reid Scott as Brett Anderson / Second Butler (voice)

Molly Shannon as Business Woman (voice)

Matt Ballard as First Butler / Reporter Matt (voice)

Eric Bauza as Anchorman Eric (voice)

Tommy Blacha as Pharmacist (voice)

Becky Boxer as Anchorwoman Donna (voice)

Richard Christy as Confused Woman (voice)

Dana Davis as Detective Cassidy (voice)

John Ennis as Detective Donahue (voice)

Julie Galdieri as Reporter Cathy (voice)

Sal Governale as Fire Chief (voice)

Jess Harnell as Reporter Jess (voice)

Sally Kirkland as Older Woman (voice)

Christopher McCulloch as Publicist (voice)

Scott Mosier as Policeman (voice)

Laraine Newman as Mrs. McCullers (voice)

Georgette Perna as Youngster (voice)

Shannon Prynoski as Dispatcher Voice (voice)

Paul Scheer as Marvin Masterson (voice)

Laura Silverman as Policewoman (voice)

Brendon Small as Mr. Kelly (voice)

Dana Snyder as Confused Guy #2 (voice)

Lily Sparks as Waitress (voice)

Bob Stephenson as Friendly Cop / Confused Guy #1 (voice)

Cree Summer as Reporter Sassy (voice)

Chloe Trujillo as French Maid (voice)

Dave Willis as Timmy (voice)

Charlyne Yi as Becky (voice)