Vella Lovell as Holly Jenkins

Cheyenne Jackson as Frank Clüsterfünke

Ana Gasteyer as Hildy Clüsterfünke

Rachel Dratch as Marga Clüsterfünke

Ryan McPartlin as Chancington Winterthorpe V

Maya Rudolph as Shania Gary (Angel)

Nils Hognestad as Percy Sleigh

Michael Benyaer as Marty

Aaron Douglas as Windmere

Kwasi Thomas as Jackie

Sharon Crandall as May

Alia Domino as No-Brow Janet

Christine Lippa as Canadian-Sounding Mayor

Duane Keogh as Postman Steve

Pippa Mackie as Waiter (Cocoa Kiosk)

Amanda Huxtable as Redhead Mom

Connor O'Mahony as Redhead Kid

Daylin Willis as Kenny (Assistant)

Aiyanna Miorin as Little Holly

David Milchard as Holly's Dad

Kerën Burkett as Holly's Mom

Ken Godmere as Old Timey Doctor

Kazumi Evans as Bestie

Brendan Riggs as New York Man

Brian E.B. Leslie as Airport Santa